Supergirl Sucks Now…And Here Is Why

The Demise of CatCo

When the show moved to The CW which precipitated that production move from Los Angeles to Canada, it was pretty much a given that Calista Flockhart wouldn’t be coming along and the show was going to lose Cat Grant. Boy, did I underestimate just how much of a loss that would be. With Cat gone the show lost the person Kara went to for advice and I mean Kara not Supergirl. Cat Grant was a pivotal person in the life of Kara Danvers and oh so instrumental in Kara’s development as a person not a superhero. With Cat gone Kara was rudderless and the show did not take any opportunity to fill that void despite having characters in place to actually do so.

The role of career mentor could have gone to Snapper Carr as he had the same acidic personality as Cat and was also a veteran journalist but instead Snapper would just show up briefly to bark and growl at Kara and not really become a part of her life or a person she felt comfortable reaching out to for guidance. James was handed Cat’s job and in that role he could have provided a lot of what Cat did especially if his hurt feelings about being dumped plus Kara’s disapproval about his side gig as a vigilante were factored into how these two dealt with one another. But instead James was backburnered for most of the season.
And worst of all the show took Kara out of CatCo completely! Even when she was still working there it was like she didn’t work there as most of her time was spent at The DEO but then she was officially fired from the place that she had so much of her life and dreams invested in and instead of showing her reeling from that loss the show instead had her acting like a goofy schoolgirl in her first relationship. Losing her budding career and being ousted from the place that was as much home to her as any other place on Earth should have been a more emotional hit but Season 2 Kara only seems to have her emotions invested in Mon-el and nothing else.


  1. V Donovan · April 24, 2017

    While I disagree with a few of these points (mainly the Sanvers ones), for the most part, this is all accurate. Season 2 has been pretty bad, and almost all its faults are due to Mon-El. It’s really unfortunate because the show was breaking barriers when it started, and it was really good, but now it’s just a mess. Hopefully the writers get their act together and listen to the feedback and make S3 better.


    • Derek · April 24, 2017

      Its like the insertion of Mon-el removed all the heart and originality from the show and now it is just another CW show. And not a particularly good one.


  2. Crimson · May 2, 2017

    I agree with almost every point here and i’m glad I’m not the only one who’s getting increasingly annoyed with this show. The only thing I really disagree with is the idea of Rhea being a good villain. She’s just another infuriating, overbearing mother villain, an overused trope, really. The worst part about it is it never is even a good villain. They’re almost always nothing more than heels as opposed to being actual villains, using the same lines (always along the same vein as, “I know what’s best next for you,(insert offspring name)”). It’s boring, overused, and simply is an easy way to piss off the audience. That’s why the mother villain types are heels. All they’re capable of doing is angering the audience. They’re not clever or even remotely smart or appealing. A good villain is one you can almost agree with and see their point of view or one that pops up suddenly during a well concealed twist, but from the get-go Rhea was pretty much introduced to be another psycho-mom.

    I’m sorry about the rant here, I just had to endure another episode on the cw website and I just really can’t stand the show, but I’m forced to watch it because, as is the case with comic books, themselves, you gotta keep up with it for the sake of crossovers. I swear, I’d stop watching forever if I knew they’d never do another crossover involving this show.

    I also gotta thank you for pointing out the problem with the Maggie/Alex relationship. It always felt off, and I never knew why until I read what you wrote, so thank you! Very insightful.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Derek · May 6, 2017

      It is possible I just enjoy Teri Hatcher going full board in the role and am comparing her favorably to Mama Luthor who was a really weak villain and basically the same character: evil overbearing mother.

      Thanks for commenting btw!


  3. Will · May 6, 2017

    I quit the show because of Mon el.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Derek · May 6, 2017

      I think I might be doing the same if he sticks around as a full cast member next season.


    • Paps · February 18, 2018

      And I because of the über annoying Alex/Maggie thing.


  4. F. Amily Mann · May 18, 2017

    Story line is full of left wing cliche’s and it sucks bad. The commentary on US politics presented in the most recent episode – alien invasion and “the resistance” – give me a break with this garbage.


    • Derek · May 18, 2017

      They have been pretty heavy-handed with it and even then they lost control of whatever narrative they were going for as the Daxamite invasion kinda proved Mama Luthor right that aliens are a pretty big threat if left unchecked.


      • Krypton · April 12, 2018

        Weedy supergirl , not enough flying scenes & stupid looking aliens that all look like humans with a bad mask. Also they need to make their mind up when it comes to Kara fighting, someone who is so fast always gets hit & punches so slowly that she often misses the target.

        She is able to lift a million tons but gets knocked to the ground by every opponent.

        The scripts are complete Crap. Shame as in 2018 it should be Fab !!


    • Your comments posted here nearly 2 years ago led to babies in cages, and hundreds who will never be reunited with their parents because they aren’t old enough to know their names. Uhhh… congratulations?


  5. Fideen · May 23, 2017

    I agree wholheartedly with your observations and analysis. The whole Alex/Maggie dynamic is contrived at best….. Unbelievable in !


    • Derek · May 23, 2017

      It really has not been very well written.
      Thanks for commenting btw.


  6. Rye · June 27, 2017

    The show gets more and more stupid the more I watch it. Horrible CGI and even worse the acting is bad. They cut Cat Grant out and that was
    a blessing but only to add in more stupid action and off the wall decision making of Supergirl. They need to stop adding in side kicks and off the wall heroes like Guardian and Mon-El. Probably the biggest reason I quit watching Arrow was because of bad character development and lame action scenes. Half of the characters are lame.The CW really needs to quit sticking Flash in every season.


    • Derek · June 27, 2017

      The inconsistent characterization of Supergirl in S02 was a major issue fro me as well as the totally unnecessary inclusion of Mon-El.


  7. Mon El · October 24, 2017

    Supergirl scriptwriting has become atrocious. It’s extremely difficult to get through an episode with such crappy scripts. The actors are amazing but with poor scripts, they can only do so much. I’m ready to close supergirl FOREVER, please cancel before it gets any worse.


    • Derek · October 24, 2017

      I hate to agree because I was hoping the new season would have some changes for the better but 3 episodes in and I am just as dissatisfied with the show now as I was when I wrote this article.


  8. Jul · October 27, 2017

    It’s definitely a depressing thought, we all contemplated how a nice entertaining show went completely bad.
    I was a very intense fan when the show was on it’s first season, now I can’t even bring myself to watch the new episodes.
    That new character, the Mon-el kid, was the beginning of the big fall that surely the show will never recover from.
    In my opinion he is one of the worst things that happened, he took away the superhero and as you just said made her a supergirlfriend. It’s ridiculous and really upsetting, probably the channel will keep renewing it, but I doubt the show will ever recover. To me it is cancelled anyway.
    Thank you for this article, I was looking for opinions to know if others feel as I do, it’s quite a relief to know they do, and judging by the latest ratings, we’re a lot of people.


    • Derek · November 3, 2017

      I am not feeling confidence in the show getting back to form based on the first few episodes of this season but I hope I am wrong. I am at least going to give it till the crossover before I decide whether to remove Supergirl from my DVR or not.


  9. Robert · December 22, 2017

    I think the problem is unfortunately the show runners and writers are just not very good. You focused on what Mon El did to Supergirl, but I also think they made him too puppy dog good too soon also. He went from “frat boy” to angel just way too fast.

    I was way on board with deep sixing the chemistry free romance between James ad Kara, although it was ham-fisted the way they broke them up. They simply had no chemistry and I really think the James character was miscast. He plays the character just “too adult” and Benoist plays Kara as almost an innocent. (she asks Mon El if he “liked, liked” her..what woman over the age of 20 still talks like that?) It was a bad match.

    But also, the villains (all except Reign, and it might be too little too late) have been awful, the plot holes are immense, they do not handle tone very well and seem to have really no plan for the characters. (the extreme left wing politics certainly did it no favors in the rating either) Maybe CBS could have saved this, but I am thinking if any DC show gets the ax on the CW, it might be this one. Unlike the “Flash” and the other shows, Supergirl actually seems to be shrinking in the face of lower rating expectations. It is playing down to lower expectations and doing it badly


    • Derek · December 23, 2017

      All valid points and it would be sad if the show were to die because nobody behind the scenes recognized that the current showrunners don’t have the talent to make an entertaining show that doesn’t insult the intelligence of the viewers.

      Thanks for posting and happy holidays!


  10. Vern · May 3, 2018

    What started well got CW’d and frankly the story, action, lame acting, and character neutering, makes me want to barf.

    I figured the super hero roll model show would end once everyone realized super girl was in super xxx rated videos…but wait let’s set her sister up as a lesbian!

    All sale – no substance. The worst show getting worse. Cancel or move to Netflixs for some real T & A scenes at least.


  11. REED RICHARDS · June 26, 2018

    Supergirl does indeed suck. And some of the reasons not mentioned: 1. Alex was never meant to be a lesbian. The CW feels that there must be a gay/lesbian character on every show. It would be a marvel if Supergirl did not have a gay or lesbian character. 2. J’onn is not Kara’s and Alex’s father. Jeremiah Danvers is. 3. J’onn should be in superhero mode, not trying to raise someone else’s grown adult children. 4. Sick and tired of the Alex Danvers as the Atomic Brunette. Totally unstoppable against anyone, alien or human. It’s BS at its core. 5. Finally, Kara Danvers is not Supergirl material. Laura Vandevoort’s Smallville Supergirl fits the bill here…………


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.