1. Randy Meeks

Randy’s death was a true shocker and really gutted me as Randy was my favorite character from the original SCREAM and I really didn’t think that any of the “Big Four” were in any real jeopardy in this franchise. But Randy not only got killed by Ghostface, he got absolutely butchered after delivering some pretty ballsy trash talk to the killer over the phone. Once the news van door slid open and Ghostface pulled Randy into the van my mouth dropped open and stayed that way for a good 10 minutes afterwards. This death hit me the hardest (and I wish it never happened at all) but it was so shocking and so well done that it is unquestionably claims the #1 spot on this list.